Wednesday, September 16, 2009

Literacy - So What?

Being illiterate is an honorable trait. Honorable in the sense that a person can go through life without the knowledge of how to read. Yet, we say that illiterate people are worthless. Is that not what you said, Hedges? Our society is becoming more and more illiterate. So, what is the purpose of an illiterate human? Are they worthless? Are they perpetually shunned to “punch in orders on cash registers?”

I wonder at your meaning, Hedges. It is as if you are saying that those who are illiterate cannot do anything worth doing? You refer to the illiterate as “they” and “them.” As if you could look in a restaurant and say, “Look at him; he is illiterate.” Being literate is not important. There are many examples of illiterate people who have lived out their lives. I personally know several. So, that is why I cannot, in the slightest, agree that there is no purpose for someone who has had no experience in being literate.

The older generation had several important priorities. Reading was not one of them. We preferred to look after our future, the next generation. Is it not true that what our ancestors “suffered” for with not being literate, has helped further the human race? Are there not more students who attempt a college education now than ever before? Thus, the illiterate are a dying breed. But, you said that the semi-illiterate are the ones who “punch in orders on cash registers.” I wonder if you know that most restaurants require a high school diploma.

Of course, illiterate people are out there in the world, but though they are illiterate, it is obvious that they are good at something. Some examples can include but are not limited to: construction workers, machinists, mechanics, farmers, etc. Without those people that have strengths in other things, where would the foundation of this country be? We need people who are good at other things than just reading. Therefore, I ask, so what if people are illiterate? Are they useful is the main question.

1 comment:

  1. I love the point you bring up about illiterate ancestors. For centuries people have contributed to society without knowing how to read or write. Even though this is now considered basic knowledge, you can't deem a person useless because they can't perform the aforementioned tasks.

    ReplyDelete